by Carl Mays II
One of the key advantages of billing outsourcing, when it is done correctly, is the clear alignment of incentives between the practice and the billing company.
Almost all medical billing companies are paid a percentage of what they collect. This means they are only paid when you are paid. It also means the more they collect for your practice, the more they are paid. Internal medical billers, on the other hand, are almost always hourly employees. They are paid based on showing up in your office, not based upon how well they perform your medical billing or how much money they collect for your practice. This is not an alignment of incentives.
Most people would prefer all their service providers to have “skin in the game” and only be paid for success versus just for making an attempt. For instance, would you prefer to pay your mechanic only if he properly fixed your car (and only for a previously agreed to price) or would you prefer to pay him an hourly rate and hope he will be as effective and efficient as possible in performing the job?
In a conversation I had recently with a busy cardiologist I heard a story that is not unusual. One of the office’s medical billers called in sick. Some information was needed while she was out so the office manager went looking through her desk. She did not find the information she needed, but she did find over $40,000 worth of claims that had not been billed and had gone beyond the timely filing deadline. That is right, $40,000 worth of claims that could not be billed and for which no money would ever be realized. Upon the billers return she was “sternly reprimanded for this egregious error. Not fired, but reprimanded for costing the practices tens of thousands of dollars. There is no alignment of incentives present in a situation like this.
This reaction is surprisingly common. Typically practices have so much trouble recruiting, training and retaining billing staff they are reticent to let one go. In addition, the billing staff complains about how understaffed they are and how they cannot be held responsible for not being able to complete even basic medical billing tasks. In this office’s case they moved the biller to the front desk and had her in charge of collecting patient demographics. A place where she can do even more harm through poor performance.
This volume of missing charges should not have gone unnoticed. There should have been multiple reports that could have identified such a problem. The practice, unfortunately, did not know how to properly utilize the capabilities of the billing system and so, the required reports were never run. Proper use of a billing system requires much investment in time and training, an investment that hourly employees often do not make. This $40,000 in unbilled charges is likely a proverbial roach of this practice - in other words, for the one you see there are likely hundreds you do not.
Utilizing a medical billing company is not a panacea for such situations, but if you insure the following actions are built into your agreement with the billing service, you should be in good shape:
- A fully integrated tracking system (charges by locations/provider and payments by source - lock box, office, PO Box) should be in place and you should have full visibility into the system at all times.
- Your medical billing company should reimburse your practice for what you would have been paid by the payers based on your allowable for any claims that go past timely filing for reasons within the medical billing company’s control. What this means is that you never suffer financially if the billing company drops the ball. Try to have your billers reimburse you if they drop the ball.
- You should have access to the billing system so that you can see real time status of your account.
We often hear from the physicians how hard and long they work for ever decreasing reimbursements. All this is true. However, too often we also see practices (through various reasons) hurt themselves financially - over and over again.
No - your staff will not work harder for you just because you employ them; and No - the biller who lost you $40,000 will not do any better job collecting money and gathering information from patients. You will probably need to “sternly” reprimand them again.
Selecting a world-class medical billing service that provides total visibility into their process and has incentives that are fully aligned with those of the practice is the most reliable road to outstanding medical billing and financial excellence.
Copyright 2008 by Carl Mays II
About the Author:
Carl Mays II, Founder and Chairman of ClaimCare
Medical Billing Services, is a medical billing and process design expert. Carl has been working in the medical field for more than 12 years. Prior to that Carl worked as an aeronautical engineer for Boeing. Read more about
medical billing companies at ClaimCare’s medical billing blog.